Please Critique Our Casino Rating System on Casino.My - Built on a Shoestring!

[Franky]

Hi GPWA community,
We’re excited to share our casino rating system on Casino.My, a project we’ve put together quickly to help players find the best online casino bonuses and experiences. The idea is to rank casinos based on key factors like bonus value, wagering requirements, game variety, and player feedback, but we know it’s still rough around the edges.

Since this was built “on the knee” with limited resources, we’d love your honest feedback to help us refine it. What works well? What feels clunky or unclear? Are there critical features or metrics we’re missing to make the ratings more useful for players? Any suggestions on improving the UI or making the system more transparent would be hugely appreciated.

Check out the rating system at https://casino.my and let us know your thoughts. We’re all ears and ready to iterate based on your expertise!

[Cash Bonus]

Your website actually loaded very quickly on my mobile phone and I like the design and theme that you've implemented, all throughout it. Agreed with dannyx and for sure it has great potential and in that being said, you should definitely expand the website even further.

[dannyx]

The site is clean and I like the color scheme. A good start for further development. Although looking at the .my domain, when I went to the site I thought I would see a Malaysian casino site.

[Franky]

Any information on the demand in Malaysia? Maybe it makes sense to translate the website into some Asian languages?

[newcustomeroffer]

Looks good, I like the QR code idea - it would be interesting to see how that converts over a regular link.

[Franky]

The basic idea: to guide the player from the desktop version to the phone. There is an opinion that this will increase the conversion rate, mobile is always at hand ))

[chaumi]

Don't know if it's only me, but I clicked on that CTA above the QR and got a dangerous page warning. A problem you might have is the QR is not marked itself to tell a clicker where they are actually going. So, they'll potentially click on the link/CTA above (because that does tell them the destination) and then (f they get the same warning) you've probably lost them.

[universal4]

I just tried the link and it sent to vavada...and I have avast running and it is not very forgiving on many scripts and did not see any issue, but he might have already changed the landing page.

Rick
Universal4

[Franky]

It's probably about Chrome's behaviour in the mobile version. I've recently noticed various notifications when redirecting via TDS. This is probably how they fight phishing.... so going directly to QR is preferable.

[CasinoDoc]

The ranking is well thought out, with a good balance between bonus value and real conditions. The interface is clean, but it would benefit from visual badges for exclusive or no-wager bonuses. This would help catch users' attention more effectively.

[NoDepositCasinos]

The ranking is well thought out, with a good balance between bonus value and real conditions. The interface is clean, but it would benefit from visual badges for exclusive or no-wager bonuses. This would help catch users' attention more effectively.

I agree with this. I tend to prefer minimalist or clean designs, but I think adding a few strategic visuals like badges, images, or even something as simple as highlighted text could improve readability and help users scan the content more easily. Also, I’d suggest including a few more links within the text. For example, I was reading one of your guides that suggests exploring current bonus codes, and my immediate thought was: “Where?” The info is there, but it would be much more convenient for users to give them the link directly instead of making them search for it.