
Originally Posted by
chaumi
Possibly the biggest clues might come from understanding how/why it did well in the first place. Did you even really deserve to be there.
First instinct would be it may have been benefiting from some form of freshness boost, though it would seem odd that it's dropped in both. I'd be looking to see what's happened to those competitor pages that were around it before. Have they gone too? If not, how are they structured? Wildly different to your page?
Also..how long has it been gone? A drop may not really be a drop until some time (unknown) has passed. It could pop back in (though again, fairly sinister that it's gone from both).
Have you checked that someone didn't copy it and are now ranking with the 'new' page (and you've been demoted as duplicate)?
While it was ranking, were visitors interacting?
All guesswork. Likely it'll be good to know the page/search term for anyone to go deeper.
If you're absolutely sure there's nothing wrong technically with it, then content improvement/enhancement may be worth a try. A link (external or from another internal page, or both). Or match the structure to whatever else ranks (assuming yours was different and/or the competition is holding steady ranking)