IMO the value can drastically change based on:
a) The traffic acquisition sources and their longevity. For SEO dependent sites a major aspect is the link profile. None wants to pay 36 months for a house of cards apparently 
There are sites that have certain appeal and are community-based though making SEO somewhat irrelevant. If You look at LCB for example, they are still kicking ass, even though the site was severely penalized years ago. They were wise enough to build one of the best sites in their niche and an active community around that.
A website like this would obviously be worth way more than top10casinosblahblah with 500 links bought on irrelevant sites with high MJ trust flow, even if they currently rank 1st for "online casino" or whatever.
b) The markets players are coming from. Illegal/grey markets are generally valued at lower multiples due to risks involved. Markets such as the US have very few affiliate programs that I would say are legitimate. Every day You basically live in fear that the program can shut down with a potential player base worth a cool million.
c) The deals You have in place. If Your 5k/month income is based on 25% revenue share and You are bought out by a major affiliate, it's likely that they have a better deal. If they agree to pay 30 months/income and have a 50% deal, essentially they are giving You 15 months.
Hope this is a bit helpful.
Making hundreds of dollars in the always emerging markets.