I prefer clean templates as they make banners, images and headlines stand out more. Although my personal favorite has always been a black site with white text, that just doesn't work. The ideal is to have an invisible template which only arranges the content. For any graphical content such as module headlines, I prefer to use typography instead of graphics.
A template should be a framework for content, nothing more. If you look at the most popular sites on the planet, including YouTube, Google and Amazon, they're mostly white, and the arrangement of content is creating the experience. Styling is minimal.
Overlay is my favorite from the four. Forex seems a bit too shy, like it's for accountants. Double Up seems outdated (I think you're stuck with those ugly black gradient module headers), and Casinotown is too dark.
With Overlay you can design yourself a clean, professional and modern site, IMO.
Professional bizdev can help you, the affiliate, to negotiate better terms with casinos. PM for details and a free evaluation of what I can do for you. All geos.