This is my first successful website I ever made: http://www.optionsadvice.com

I started it in 2013 (after multiple failed attempts at affiliating for several years) and made it to make some nice money. Right now it's at around $4,000-$5,000 per month constantly for like the last 8-ish months. Might not be much for many people here but consider this is the first site I succeeded making money with.

However I seem to have gotten stuck at this level and I am not sure what to do to push it even more. Any ideas are welcome (i.e. change in design, SEO, PPC, content, CTAs etc. etc.). I intend to keep this site for long term, so I'm not interested in pure black hat SEO spam that would boost it overnight but then get it penalized a few months after.

Thanks.