If you'd just rate programs then you already got AGD for that. They're doing a great job at dissecting T&Cs.
The whole point of this is to actively involve members and give them a certain degree of responsibility, empower them. E.g. some things can be tolerated like Shay said, some we don't care about, while some are deal breakers. If a member is actively promoting a program that's blacklisted by the union, then he/she automatically excluded him/herself from the union.
That's the whole point. You earn your membership by actively refusing to promote rogue programs. Period. That's what this is about - grouping such people together.
You can't be a member and have all members refuse to promote a certain program while you'll be a smartass and get all the signups with that program - and still be a member.
On the other hand, members get a strengthened negotiating position and the liberty to use The Document.
But this is very, very complex. For example, can a webmaster who promotes only the good programs but sends out spam be a member? What if a good money-making program goes rogue, should all members stop promoting the program and commit a financial suicide?
So many complex things so it's best to come up with very simple rules for a start. Such as, this will be a group of people that only promote programs that fulfill the most important criteria of the union.
Just my 5c.
Professional bizdev can help you, the affiliate, to negotiate better terms with casinos. PM for details and a free evaluation of what I can do for you. All geos.