Whew. That was one-long-read.
I feel bloated now

I was going to read from the second-to-last page and on forward, but someone mentioned negative stuff said about GPWA, AGD, and others.... so I read the whole thing.
I really didn't see much negative about AGD although I did see some about GPWA and APCW.
I think that saying GPWA and others (yes, that includes AGD) are 'without teeth' or haven't done enough for the industry is a bit on the ignorant side (sorry if that sounds harsh). If people want to take 1 or 2 instances out of hundreds or thousands, then I will say to them.... 99% or 99.9% success rate is better than the uptime on your servers.

It's quite respectable - and nothing is perfect.
Will a union work? Maybe. I wouldn't disparage it. I would also expect the same courtesy be applied to both GPWA and AGD.
Dave has some great ideas here and the Union may help organizations like GPWA/APCW/GIA/AGD/CM (and any others I may have forgotten) in their fight to keep the industry clean. I, personally, hope there are some successes.
It will be interesting, on October 1st, to get some of the questions in the thread answered.